Diffusion, osmosis and active transport: the differences

Diffusion is net movement down a concentration gradient; osmosis is water movement across a selectively permeable membrane. Active transport couples transport to an energy source and can move a substance against its electrochemical gradient. A membrane protein does not automatically make transport active: channels and some carriers support passive transport. Identify the substance, membrane permeability and driving force before choosing an answer.

In an IMAT biology question, “through a protein” is not enough information to identify the transport mechanism. Start by following one substance across the membrane.

Compare the mechanisms

MechanismWhat crosses?Direction and energyExample
Simple diffusionA permeable substanceDown its gradient; no coupled cellular energy supplyOxygen crossing a lipid bilayer
Facilitated diffusionA substance using a channel or carrierDown its electrochemical gradient; passiveAn ion through an open channel
OsmosisWaterDown its water-potential gradient; passiveWater crossing through aquaporins
Primary active transportA pump’s transported substrateDirect energy input can drive uphill transportThe sodium–potassium ATPase
Secondary active transportCoupled substancesOne downhill movement powers another uphill movementSodium-coupled glucose uptake

For charged particles, consider both concentration and electrical forces. OpenStax’s active-transport chapter explains this electrochemical gradient and the distinction between direct and indirect energy coupling.

Water moves; the trapped solute does not

For dilute solutions at equal pressure, water initially moves towards the side with the higher concentration of solute particles that cannot cross the membrane. Pressure differences can oppose that movement, so “water always moves towards more solute” is an incomplete rule.

Original example: two compartments contain 0.10 mol/L and 0.30 mol/L sucrose. The membrane permits water but blocks sucrose; initial pressures are equal.

Water initially moves from the 0.10 mol/L side to the 0.30 mol/L side. Do not draw sucrose moving in the opposite direction: the question explicitly blocks it. Nor does this initial prediction prove that the final concentrations must become equal; a developing pressure difference may balance the osmotic driving force.

OpenStax’s passive-transport chapter covers osmosis, permeability and tonicity.

Isotonic does not mean motionless

A solution is described as hypotonic, isotonic or hypertonic relative to a cell. Tonicity concerns the effect on cell volume and depends on effectively non-penetrating solutes.

In an isotonic environment, water still crosses in both directions. Equal opposing flows mean no net change, not that individual molecules stop. Keep this distinction between movement and net movement whenever a question mentions equilibrium.

A protein is a route, not proof of an energy source

Consider two imaginary experiments:

  • In experiment A, an uncharged molecule moves through a carrier from 8 mmol/L outside to 2 mmol/L inside, without coupling to another process. This is consistent with facilitated diffusion.
  • In experiment B, that molecule accumulates inside against its gradient while sodium enters down its own electrochemical gradient through the same coupled transporter. This is consistent with secondary active transport.

The useful difference is the coupling, not simply the presence of a carrier. Secondary transport need not consume ATP at that transporter, but maintaining the gradient that powers it can require ATP elsewhere.

Self-check: what can you conclude?

These are original practice prompts, not past-paper questions.

1. Water enters a cell through aquaporins. Is that active transport?
No. A channel can speed passive water movement; using a protein does not itself establish energy coupling.

2. A membrane blocks both solutes in a two-compartment experiment. Which way does water move?
You cannot decide from permeability alone. You also need the relevant concentrations and pressure conditions.

3. ATP production stops. Must every sodium-coupled transporter stop immediately?
Not necessarily. An existing sodium gradient may briefly continue to power transport. Its subsequent loss reduces that driving force.

A three-question method

Before choosing an option, ask: What moves? Can it cross? What drives it? Write those answers beside a simple membrane sketch. This is more reliable than matching the word “protein” to “active”.

If the membrane itself is unclear, start with cell structure. If the problem presents a rate curve, use the graph-reading guide to separate the observations from the proposed mechanism.

Sources

Or keep going in the iPhone app.

Found a mistake? Write to hello@imatlearn.com